Recovering from identity theft is hard enough without self-inflicted setbacks. These are the mistakes that slow people down or cost them money.
Mistake 1: Paying the fraudulent debt. It feels like the fastest way to make collectors stop calling, but paying can imply the debt is yours. Dispute fraudulent accounts instead — you are not legally responsible for debts created through identity theft.
Mistake 2: Disputing once and moving on. If a bureau verifies an item you know is fraudulent, do not accept it. Send a follow-up dispute with your FTC Identity Theft Report attached, dispute directly with the furnisher, and escalate with a CFPB complaint if needed.
Mistake 3: Skipping the FTC report. The IdentityTheft.gov report is free, official, and strengthens every dispute you file. It also unlocks extended fraud alerts. There is no good reason to skip it.
Mistake 4: Forgetting the freeze. People dispute existing fraud but leave their files open for new fraud. Place security freezes at all three bureaus while you clean up — recovery and prevention should happen together.
Mistake 5: Trusting ‘guaranteed removal’ companies. No company can remove accurate negative information, and no company can do anything you cannot do yourself for free. Some charge steep fees for form letters you could send yourself.
Mistake 6: Giving information to unsolicited callers. After a breach or fraud incident, scammers call posing as your bank, the FTC, or a ‘fraud department.’ Real organizations do not ask for your full SSN or passwords by phone. Hang up and call back on a number you trust.
Mistake 7: Tossing the paper trail. Recovery takes months. Keep every letter, confirmation number, and call log — organized records turn follow-ups from ordeals into errands.
Join the conversation
Load Facebook comments to read and reply using your Facebook account.