File segregation is one of the oldest frauds in the credit repair world. The pitch: for a fee, a company will help you create a new credit file, separate from your real one, so your past debts and mistakes no longer follow you. It sounds like a fresh start. Under federal law, it is a crime.
How the Scheme Works
The company typically tells you to apply for an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS — a number meant for businesses — and then use it in place of your Social Security number on credit applications. Some variants sell you a made-up nine-digit number. Either way, the goal is to build credit under an identity that is not really you.
Why It Is Illegal
Using an EIN or a fake number to apply for personal credit is misrepresenting your identity on a credit application, which violates federal fraud statutes. The Credit Repair Organizations Act separately prohibits any credit repair company from advising you to make false statements in connection with credit. A company pitching file segregation is breaking at least two federal laws in one conversation.
The EIN Trap
EINs are free from the IRS and intended for business tax purposes. There is nothing illegal about having one for a real business. The crime is using it to conceal your identity from lenders. Consumers who follow this advice often do not realize they have committed fraud until a lender flags the application — or worse.
What Happens to Victims
People who buy into file segregation face closed accounts, fraud flags on their real credit files, and potential criminal prosecution. The debts in the original file do not disappear — they remain collectible, and now the consumer has fraud exposure on top of them. The fresh start leaves them worse off in every direction.
How to Recognize the Pitch
Watch for phrases like new credit identity, separate your file, use this number instead of your SSN, or legally start over. Any offer that involves applying for credit as someone you are not — even a new you — is file segregation, regardless of the marketing language.
What to Do If You Were Pitched
Do not pay, do not apply for the EIN for this purpose, and do not use any number you were given. Report the company to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general. If you already participated, talk to a consumer attorney promptly.
Your credit file is tied to your identity for a reason. Anyone offering to sever that tie is not offering freedom — they are offering fraud, with your name on it. This article is general information, not legal advice.
Why the Pitch Persists
File segregation schemes have been illegal for decades, yet the pitch keeps resurfacing under new names. It persists because the underlying desire — a clean slate — is timeless, and because each generation of consumers rediscovers the scheme without knowing its history. Sellers rebrand it constantly: new credit identity, credit profile number, secondary credit file. The vocabulary changes; the crime does not.
The persistence of the pitch is also a reminder that enforcement alone cannot protect everyone. New sellers appear faster than regulators can shut them down, especially online. Your best defense is understanding the core tell: any scheme that requires you to apply for credit as someone you are not is fraud, regardless of the terminology, the testimonials, or the supposed legal theory. When you can spot the structure beneath the branding, no rebrand can fool you.
Join the conversation
Load Facebook comments to read and reply using your Facebook account.